Why did you give up Gluten?
Is it really necessary to remove gluten entirely from your
diet? Gluten is a protein complex largely found in wheat, barley and rye and is
composed of strands of gliadin and glutenin.
It is particularly useful in baked goods as it is
structurally amenable to water absorption and enables entrapment of air to
create a moist, airy food product. It
also provides flavor. As such, bakers
are inclined to adjust the gluten content of baked goods to improve taste and
texture. This has led to the
adulteration of breads that are traditionally dry and dense with added wheat
gluten. This modification has now
produced rye breads and black breads that have the texture of an airy, moist
white bread. In and of itself, gluten
is a perfectly healthy source of protein.
However, it is not the only nutritious component of whole grains. Whole grains also contain a bran layer and a
germ layer. The bran layer contains
fiber, B vitamins and other trace minerals while the germ layer is a
nutrient-rich core containing vitamin E, B vitamins and polyunsaturated fatty
acids. Unfortunately, these nutrient dense layers are removed from whole grains
to get to the structurally useful endosperm where gluten is located.
Makers of processed foods have no practical use for the much
healthier bran and germ layers of whole grains so they practically have been
eliminated from the Standard American Diet (SAD). The gluten-containing endosperm, on the other
hand, is such a large component of the SAD diet that it is consumed in
quantities that have exceeded its health benefit. It is known that food sensitivities may be
created by over-consumption of the same products, resulting in lack of
adequacy, balance and variety. Over the
past few decades we have over-indulged on gluten-containing products to the
point that we no longer have the capacity to completely digest what was once a
perfectly healthy protein. Gluten
intolerance is not to be confused with Celiac disease, an adverse immunological
response to gliadin that leads to autoimmune destruction of the small
intestine.
As a result of a bona fide sensitivity to gluten or Celiac
disease many consumers have removed whole grains from their diets and so are
missing out on their many health benefits.
Let’s start with the bran layer.
The fiber in bran directly improves colon health, is beneficial to
healthy gut bacteria and lowers plasma cholesterol levels using a mechanism
that is free of the side-effects common to pharmaceutical agents. B vitamins, in both the bran and germ layers,
function as co-factors that are critical for cellular activity. Additional benefits of the germ layer exceed
that of any other food category. The
germ layer contains a plethora of antioxidants including vitamin E which is so
deficient in the SAD diet, along with heart-healthy fats.
I commend David Perlmutter, author of Grain Brain, for bringing to our attention the many ways that
gluten adversely effects our health and leads to cognitive decline. However, it is somewhat concerning that we
have over-interpreted his message and removed whole grains from our diets
entirely. I did a little deep dive to
see what Dr. Perlmutter is eating himself.
Although he subscribes to a ketogenic diet (high protein, low carb) he
does allow himself 50-100 g of carbohydrates per day. This includes consumption of amaranth,
buckwheat, rice (brown, white, wild), millet, quinoa, sorghum, teff and
certified gluten-free oats. These grains
are just as healthy, if not more so, than whole wheat and provide a perfectly
sound alternative for those with gluten sensitivity. More information about the benefits of these
gluten-free whole grains may be found on the Whole Grains Council website, http://wholegrainscouncil.org.